OKBNeftegazdiagnostika
Contact us ↗RU

International research

If the internal tube inspection is not yet possible: how to select the locations of external inspection

Sample ultrasound surveys, terrain, water accumulation and limits of findings on several available sealine sections.

Technical analysis · OKB editorial team5 min read
An explanatory chart of the OKB. Not experimental data from the authors of the publication.
An explanatory chart of the OKB. Not experimental data from the authors of the publication.

What is the work of Baker Hughes

The 2017 report examined the maritime oil line, which at that time did not allow for an internal inspection. The authors selected several external automated ultrasonic control locations based on an analysis of the likely internal corrosion and operational conditions. In one of the sites surveyed, minor local damage was detected; the results were used to temporarily control the condition prior to the passage.

This example does not prove that several external scans replace the full examination. It shows how to get useful information with limited access. We then consider the unique logic of selecting sites and the boundaries of local results for the whole site.

Choice of location — part of the measurement method

If only a small part of the surface is available, the quality of the solution depends on why these are chosen. The area of accessability is not necessarily the most likely place to be damaged. Therefore, technical accessibility and diagnostic representativeness should be assessed separately.

The regimes, composition of the product and the possibility of accumulation of the water phase are important for internal corrosion. Reelef helps to create hypotheses about such zones, but is not a direct measure of corrosion. The existence of conditions for accumulation does not mean imminent damage; the absence of a visible reduction does not exclude other mechanisms. The program should explain what threats are covered by the logic chosen and which remain outside it.

Hydraulic hypothesis and real data

The phase distribution model links the slope, consumption and properties of the product to the expected accumulation of liquid. It's useful for ranking the sites, but it's sensitive to the baseline data. The change in regime over the years may be more important than the state on the day of the survey.

The analysis should therefore take into account the operational history, including long periods of low consumption and stops. If the archive is incomplete, a range of scenarios should be considered. The choice of sites becomes more justified when several independent indicators point to one area. However, they cannot be considered independent if all of them are derived from one reference relief and flow model: these are only different perceptions of the same hypothesis.

Which gives an external ultrasonic scan

If access is appropriate, external scanning allows for detailed measurement of the wall on a restricted site. Interpretation requires knowing the step, the area, the quality of acoustic contact and the way in which the inner surface is determined. The local absence of a significant metal loss characterizes the area under investigation.

It's useful to keep the scan boundaries and location relative to seams and circles in the report. If the next campaign is shifted, different results may occur from another surface. The repeatable coordinate system makes local control suitable for observation over time. Without it, even an accurate device can provide little information about the growth of a particular injury because different locations are compared.

Why the quiet areas don't prove a calm path

Selective verification reduces uncertainty over the mechanisms and areas it targets. It does not automatically turn into a statistical estimate of the entire line. This distribution requires a sample model and reasons to consider the sites surveyed representative.

If the sites are selected as the most unfavourable, the negative result is useful, but its strength depends on the reliability of the ranking model. If the model missed another mechanism, control of the selected areas does not report anything. The conclusion should therefore be formulated with an indication of the threats covered and the remaining gaps. This allows the data to be used without giving them an actual completeness that is not available.

Re-monitoring and interim strategy

A risk-based and quality-consensual surveillance programme can be developed until full diagnostic accessibility is achieved. Remeasures help clarify changes in selected locations and new operational information — Re-examine the selection of points. The interim strategy should have the conditions for revision.

For example, changing a product or regime can make the previous sample less representative. The emergence of a new topic may also require another methodology. It is important to determine in advance what information is needed to move from temporary observation to a more complete survey. Otherwise, the limited programme is becoming a permanent one, although initially only as an interim measure was justified.

Engineering output of OKB

This experience shows that the diagnostic task begins before the choice of instrument: with a threat model and an object's accessibility. The exact meter on the wrong section does not give a full answer, while a limited measurement with clearly defined boundaries can significantly improve the solution.

The principle of traceability is useful for OKB: each output must be linked to the measured area, the original hypothesis and the remaining uncertainty. The development of instruments and software can support this discipline by making it easy to link, store the initial signals and compare campaigns. For the next campaign, it is useful to keep not only the coordinates of the selected sites but also the reasons for their selection. This allows the sample to be re-examined when the mode changes or new details of the damage mechanisms appear.

Engineering output

Selective control is useful if you understand why the sites are selected and what threats it covers. Local accuracy does not replace the completeness of the survey of the whole line.

Sources and further reading

The article was originally written in Russian. It summarises the cited sources. For the original text and illustrations, consult the publications listed below.