OKBNeftegazdiagnostika
Contact us ↗RU

International research

Long longitudinal corrosion: Why the calculation needs a wall profile

One maximum depth does not describe the long corrosion tunnel. We're going to go from ultrasonic map to state assessment.

Technical analysis · OKB editorial team5 min read
An explanatory chart of the OKB. The experimental data are provided in the source.
An explanatory chart of the OKB. The experimental data are provided in the source.

Problem Statement

The 2014 NDT Global Report addresses longitudinal internal corrosion of sea pipelines. The authors show the value of detailed ultrasonic data, emission filtering and residual wall profiles for the evaluation of long-term damage. The difference between the assessment of a separate anomaly and that of a line with a large number of affected sites is also discussed.

We see this work as a historical technical source. The wording of the calculation documents mentioned therein should not be automatically considered relevant. Main subject of review — The relationship between the form of damage, the processing of measurements and the justification for the engineering output.

Why size tables are not sufficient

Two corrosion areas may have the same maximum depth and total length, but different distributions of the remaining metal. In one case, the deep point is surrounded by a relatively thick wall; in another, most of the length is close to it. For calculation, it's different geometry.

A short list of anomalies is suitable for searching and ranking, but does not replace the spatial map. The format of extradition should therefore be consistent with the future task. If a complex long corrosion analysis is to be undertaken, keeping only three dimensions significantly limits the possibility of re-evaluation.

From thickness map to longitudinal profile

The profile along the pipe is based on a certain rule of choice of values from a two-dimensional map. You can follow the local deepest trajectory or use an agreed window. Choices affect the outcome, especially when the channel is circular or adjacent to individual ulcers.

The method of construction shall be reproducible. It is important to maintain the original map, the width of the search area, the step and the rules for handling passes. Then the engineer can understand what physical damage the line is. Without this information, a smooth graph of residual thickness can hide substantially different reference surface conditions.

Filtering requires physical verification

The sherry corrosion surface may cause unstable reflections and separate emissions. But the deepest real ulcer also looks like a local minimum. Therefore, the automatic removal of all sharply different points can destroy an important defect.

It is useful to analyse the consistency of neighbouring channels, the form of echo signal and the repeatability of the sign. The filter must have a clear basis and retain the mask of the modified data. A comparison of the original and processed profile allows us to assess how much the final calculation depends on the decision of the algorithm. If this dependence is high, the area requires more attention than more smoothing.

Multiple sites and total risk

When similar corrosion occurs on a large number of tubes, the assessment of only the deepest measurement may be insufficient. Each section has its own uncertainty, and the set of sites forms a systemic problem. The weakness does not always coincide with the maximum depth recorded.

The analysis is based on the thickness, length of damage, load and data quality across the line. This information cannot be replaced by a single "model" profile without checking its representativeness. In doing so, the statistical association of the sites must take into account the common causes of damage and the relationship between errors or the calculation is not reasonably certain.

How to Project Channel Change

Longitudinal corrosion can develop not only deep, but also in length and width. Therefore, the projection for one maximum point does not describe a change in the effective area of metal loss. Re-inspection requires a combination of maps themselves, not just lists of the deepest ones.

The difference between actual shape change and measurement grid change is necessary. A closer survey may reveal an previously unrecorded minimum that would be mistaken for rapid growth. It is useful to bring the data to a comparable spatial basis and to separately assess the impact of resolution and error model.

What needs to be obtained from the measurement system

The meaningful assessment requires a map of thickness, signal quality, nominal wall and design crossings. Identification of welds and incomplete surfaces is important. The missing values shall remain distinct from those not necessarily restored.

A good program interface allows for a transition from the profile line to the reference unbutton and signal. It helps check the disputed extremes and understand the result of the calculation. Exporting only images without numerical data dramatically reduces reproducibility: an analyst sees a form but cannot verify the rules for its receipt.

OKB Engineering Comment

This example shows why the development of the measuring instrument includes data format and tools for checking them. A detailed sensor array is useless to calculate complex corrosion if the programmable part only retains a rounded maximum. On the contrary, a well-designed data structure allows for the application of new analytical techniques to surveys already completed.

The OKB editorial conclusion is to maintain a link between the signal, map and the calculation profile. We do not propose in the article a ready assessment of permissible pressure. This conclusion requires parameters of the specific facility and a harmonized methodology rather than one illustrative graph.

Engineering output

Long corrosion describes the distribution of the remaining metal; maximum depth is only part of this information.

Sources and further reading

The article was originally written in Russian. It summarises the cited sources. For the original text and illustrations, consult the publications listed below.