OKBNeftegazdiagnostika
Contact us ↗RU

International research

Hydrogen or CO₂ pipeline conversion: why the previous survey is not sufficient

How a change in transportable environments is rebuilding the list of threats, data requirements and the validation program for the existing line.

Technical analysis · OKB editorial team5 min read
An explanatory chart of the OKB. Not experimental data from the authors of the publication.
An explanatory chart of the OKB. Not experimental data from the authors of the publication.

What was the 2021 publication about?

The ROSEN report reviews the use of existing infrastructure for the transport of hydrogen and carbon dioxide. The authors discuss changes in the mechanisms for damage, material information requirements and characteristics of internal tube surveys. These two environments are combined with the task of re-evaluation of suitability, but not the same physics of interaction with design.

The review does not reproduce projections of energy networks from work as relevant information. We are interested in the engineering principle: a positive history of exploitation with an old product does not prove fit for a new purpose. A self-review of which issues need to be linked in the preparation of the evaluation programme is further provided.

First, the threat model changes.

The same geometry of the pipe does not mean the same risk in another environment. The importance of cracks, corrosion, cyclical loads and seal conditions is determined by a combination of material, product composition and mode. The list of diagnostic tasks should therefore be taken from the new operating scenario rather than automatically transferred from the previous programme.

It is convenient to start with the table of changes: composition and contamination, pressure, temperature, cycling, possible transition modes. The affected element and the necessary information shall be provided for each line. This sequence allows you to see the gaps before selecting the instrument. Otherwise, a qualitative survey could be repeated in the usual way that does not answer the main question of new application.

Hydrogen and material information

For hydrogen-containing environments, the characteristics of a specific metal and welds are important, not just the strength class designation. The behaviour of the material depends on structure, manufacture, tension and exposure conditions. The wall thickness measurement provides the necessary geometric information, but does not automatically describe resistance to crack development in the changed environment.

Historical passports, test results and repair data should be compared with the actual location of the pipe sections. If the route is collected from different batches, a single averaged property may conceal local restrictions. The material clarification programme shall be targeted: first, the areas with unknown or different characteristics are identified and then the checks are determined.

CO₂: value of composition and phase state

Carbon dioxide is a significant transport environment and contamination. The only discussion about the name of the substance is not sufficient: changes in water, temperature or pressure can change the interaction with the wall and the flow behaviour. The diagnostic programme is therefore linked to the control of operational parameters.

In an engineering model, it is useful to separate the regular range from transition events. The short-term mode may define a separate material or procedure requirement even if most of the time the line is stable. The survey records the state for a moment and suitability is in the future range of conditions. A calculation and operational transition is needed between these two allegations.

The device itself works in a new environment.

The modified product does not only affect the pipeline. The mandrels, leakproof shells, fastenings, magnetic components and instrument connections shall also be suitable. The compatibility of the material does not yet guarantee steady movement and the required quality of registration. The transport capacity of the flow and the nature of leaks through seals may differ from the usual case.

The qualification therefore includes two separate sets of evidence: the ability of the equipment to operate in the environment and the measurement characteristics at expected dynamics. Successful runs in another gas mixture should not be considered sufficient proof. The documentation shall keep the composition, pressure range, temperature conditions and actual configuration for which the test has been carried out.

Initial survey and follow-up

Before a change in assignment, it is useful to establish a baseline that is suitable for future comparison. It shall include not only the list of defects but also the completeness, method limitations and the quality of the reference. The new survey will then make it possible to distinguish between the increase in damage, the change of classification and the difference in sensitivity.

The observation plan is linked to the expected mechanisms and uncertainty of the baseline. The frequency of control is not directly derived from another's industrial example. Where material or mode data are weak, the decision may require further research before conversion. Where information is agreed, the programme can be justified on its totality, while maintaining the verifiability of each assumption.

What's important to the developer

The experience of the reorientation of infrastructure shows why the diagnostic complex should store more than the total size of anomalies. The environment, channel status and the algorithm version help to determine later whether an old recording can be used for a new task. The long-term value of data is often determined by such accompanying information.

For the OKB, the practical conclusion is to design the equipment and format of the report together. The system shall allow the measured fact to be separated from the subsequent calculation. The actual composition of the product and the history of the transition modes are particularly useful for future comparison: they make it possible to verify whether the signal change is due to damage, environmental properties or registration conditions.

Engineering output

The changing environment requires a reassessment of threats, material and diagnostics. Past experience of exploitation is useful but does not replace confirmation of a new assignment.

Sources and further reading

The article was originally written in Russian. It summarises the cited sources. For the original text and illustrations, consult the publications listed below.