OKBNeftegazdiagnostika
Contact us ↗RU

International research

Ultrasound in CRA pipes: What wall does the instrument really see?

The entire corrosion resistant material, the crying pipe and the mechanically installed liner require different ultrasonic control models.

Technical analysis · OKB editorial team6 min read
An explanatory chart of the OKB. The experimental data are provided in the source.
An explanatory chart of the OKB. The experimental data are provided in the source.

What NDT Global Work

The authors of the PPSA 2016 report are looking at ultrasonic controls of various CRA designs: a complete corrosion resistant alloy, metal-compatible layers and mechanical liner. The important conclusion of the source is that the availability of an inner surface for measurement does not mean that all layers are equally accessible. For mechanical connection, the authors note a restriction on the transmission of ultrasound to the carrying wall.

This is a useful starting point for the technical task: first, it is necessary to define the monitored layer and the type of damage expected. The phrase "measure the thickness of the pipe" for a multilayered structure is too vague.

Why the name of the material is not sufficient

The CRA designation combines different alloys and ways of making. They may differ in acoustic properties, structure, roughness and quality of the connection to the main metal. Even the same chemical composition of the protective layer does not guarantee equal ultrasonic response after different production processes.

The object ' s passport must therefore contain the structure of the wall, nominal thicknesses of layers, the way of connection and information on the transitional sections. Welding compounds are also important for the interpretation of reflections. If these data are not available, the algorithm may mistakenly assume a layer line over the outer surface or consider the loss of signal as a sign of deep corrosion.

What's going on at the layer border?

Ultrasound wave is partly reflected and partly passes across the boundary of materials. The ratio depends on acoustic properties and the state of contact. The air gap or the loose mechanical connection can dramatically change the energy path. So the time of coming in a separate echo still needs to be linked to a particular physical boundary.

It is useful to analyse not only the calculated thickness but also the form of the reference signal for a multilayer wall. Several reflections, changes in amplitude and the disappearance of expected echoes help to understand the limits of interpretation. The retention of such features in the data makes the result verifiable in the subsequent examination of the disputed site.

Inside surface and load wall

Measuring the distance from the sensor to the inner surface can show local changes in its shape. However, the measurement of the residual thickness of the load metal requires information on the opposite boundary of the layer concerned. These tasks are linked, but not identical.

For example, the safety of the protective liner does not prove that there is no external corrosion to the main pipe. Conversely, suitable load wall data do not necessarily refer to minor damage to the interior surface. The report should clearly indicate which surfaces and volumes were observed by each channel, and where the output is limited to wall design and physics.

Small pitting and spatial coating

Local ulcers can occupy a small area at significant depth. Their detection depends on the size of the acoustic stain, the steps of the sensors, the frequency of recording and the state of the surface. The reduction of the longitudinal step does not compensate for the too rare location of the sensors on a circle.

The check shall include a defect offset relative to the measurement grid. Artificial ulcer, located exactly under the axis of the converter, is a good case. Intermediant positions and actual damage are also required to assess the stability of detection. The threshold for recording, probability of detection and accuracy of depth determination should be described separately rather than "sensitive" in one word.

How to build a representative sample

The calibration sample for conventional carbon steel does not replace the sample of a multilayered pipe. Appropriate materials, thickness and connection and welding are required if they are to be used. Artificial reflectors are useful for repeatability, but do not reproduce the full spectrum of natural corrosion.

The verification programme should include known changes in each of the sectors of interest. Separately check the false interpretation of interlayeral reflection as a loss of metal. The result is desirable to be presented as a map of applicability: for which design and anomaly measurement is confirmed and for which remains limited.

How to Read Historical Characteristics

The 2016 publication describes the equipment and experience of its time. Its numbers cannot be transferred without verification to modern components or other pipelines. The material of the liner, the quality of the layer compound and the acceptable range of acoustic space are important in comparison. The work is important in addressing physical limitations and experimental logic.

It is useful to request a relevant area of expertise, acoustic contact conditions and rules for processing missing data when selecting technology. A beautiful example of a unwrapped shows that you can get an image in one case. The operational solution requires understanding how similar this case is to the specific design of the pipe being examined.

OKB Engineering Comment

In the measurement system architecture, it is useful to keep each result attached to the layer and surface. The software then does not mix the geometry of the internal channel, the thickness of the protective metal and the thickness of the bearing wall. This is particularly important when combining several control methods.

We see such publications as the basis for smart tasking and instrument development. The quality of the system is determined not by a promise to "see everything" but by the ability to accurately describe the measured amount, confirm it with a test and show the user areas where it has not been possible to obtain a reliable result.

Engineering output

For CRA, first the layer and type of damage are determined, then the physical method and the validation program are selected.

Sources and further reading

The article was originally written in Russian. It summarises the cited sources. For the original text and illustrations, consult the publications listed below.